2013 journal. I now only own an Intuos4 I have sold my cintiq 13hd. but this may still be relevant for some.
-----------
This is going to be a huge review.
Before I even continue i'd like to start by saying what needs to be said. A TABLET will NOT make you a better artist. If you're reading this with that being your first mindset. Good luck with that. It WILL allow you to do digital work. It WILL increase your workflow. But if you have bad basics...doing them digitally and faster won't make them look any better. Period.
Things to know about ALL tablets:
-There is a learning curve. Whether you have a cintiq OR an intuos/bamboo.
-You can use different nibs in all wacom tablet products MINUS the bamboo
-They will last you long if you treat them well (don't bend the damn chords and man handle them)
- I use a smudgeguard glove on ALL MY TABLETS.
Tablets I have used:
-Bamboo Create
-Intuos 3
-Intuos 4
-Intuos 5
-Cintiq 12wx
-Cintiq 21ux
-Cintiq 13hd
-Cintiq 22hd
*I'll also give my feels on the companion and companion hybrid and an alternative to the two.
The Bamboo Create:
This was my FIRST TABLET EVER. It did NOT stay with me long. I think it's a great and affordable tablet for beginners who can't start with an intuos. I honestly hated the pen. The lack of work space. And the pressure sensitivity gap between it vs a pencil. I felt i had to put too much effort into pressing to get it to work well. This was really flustering for someone with small hands and a light touch like me.
All in all I'd say its great for starters who need to get a hang of looking up a screen to work. And with the 30 day money back gaurantee. If you can take care of it. you can send it back. get your refund. and get an intuos small when you're ready.
Intuos 3:
Hate it. Hate it. Hate it.
I loved all the hotkeys. Sure. But the screen felt awful. The pen felt awful. Perhaps i'm biased seeing as I used it AFTER I had used the more stream lined intuos 4 but that doesnt make me hate it any less. It's bulky as hell too...just...no.
I don't have many words on this.
If you can get a 4. Get a 4. I dont even feel like the 3 is worth giving a shot.
Intuos 4.
One of my current babies. My second ever tablet who I've used for 2 years and going strong. I LOVE IT. Does it have less hotkeys than a intuos 3 yes. but more than a bamboo. And honestly with how i hear how many people dont' even set their hotkeys....8 is more than enough. The touch ring was BRILLIANT to begin including. it lets you change brushe sizes swiftly and like a dream. 2048 levels of pressure sensitivity is great and you can really tell! Hatching is awesome on it. The pen is sturdy and the drawing surface is very lightly textured so it feels good with all the nibs. However my personal favorite is the flexnib to use with it. Comeing straight from pencil to digital. THIS is my reccommended starting tablet to those who can afford it.
It's a good sturdy tablet that i've had no issues with at all.
Intuos 5
If you just have to have the damn touch features that the 4 doesn't have. Fine....get this thing. Otherwise it's EXACTLY THE SAME as a 4 aside from that.
And legit most people turn the touch recognition OFF anyway. So what is the point paying 100 more for the 5 and you'll be turning off the main features that seperates it from a 4?
It's a waste of extra cash.
Cintiq 12wx:
coming from paper to, intuos, to a cintiq you are bound to fall in love with it at first. till you note the flaws.
-The resolution
-The color calibration
-The driver jumps
-The screen size
Other people will mention there are too many cables. I honestly had no issues with that. for a cintiq priced at 500 dollars? I can deal with some cables.
I could NOT deal with the flaws i mentioned.
The screen while only an inch smaller than the 13hd...is in actuallity much smaller due to the resolution differences. I had to constantly tab my sai to make it ok to work on.
The Colors will not be able to match a newer computer no matter what unless you buy a separate piece. being the spyder callibrating system. The old ones being 80 dollars USED. and the new ones? 165 some odd dollars.
you also need a cable converter which is about 10+ dollars. because it doesnt have hdmi hookup.
The drivers conflict if you have any intuos made after the intuos 3. you have to remove preferecnes....reinstall drivers...restart computer...each time you want to work with one of the other.
So...for the 12wx to work well it needs almost 100+ more dollars sunk into it. still cheaper than a 13hd. but worth it? idk.
if you have an older computer and a much older tablet. this may work well for you anyway. especially if you plan to make it your new main tablet. I however wanted to be able to integrate my intuos and cintiq.
Cintiq 13hd:
My only problem with this thing.
My ONLY PROBLEM...
Is that fucking rocker wheel. They did NOT THINK THIS THROUGH ALL THE WAY. It's a very slow way to do shit. I HATE HATE HATE IT. I almost feel as if they did it on purpose.....because i bet you anything a touch wheel version comes out next year and i PROMISE YOU almost all people will spend that money on the new version because of how BAD the rocker wheel is....I legit almost didnt buy it knowing that....but...i'll juet get the touch wheel version.....when it happens. because this was too valuable to me to go another yr without.
Main benefits? Sketching and inking. I'm still skeptical on painting with it. My set up is more like this and for his reasons as well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7z63k_YDsYI
It inergrates with the intuos. It feels awesome. it has good screen room. the colors match up after you fix the settings. it calibrates well.
I use the FELT NIB on it. So there will be no scratches i've heard complaints of. Yes if you put hard ass plastic on a glass creen its prolly gonna scratch ESPECIALLY if you are heavy handed.
The cable issues people spoke of, are fixed. it isnt flimsy at all. If you ordered it as soon as it was out, yes those problems were there.
Its very light weight i can pick it up.
Once you get used to it...its great. it's just...great.
Cintiq 21ux and 22hd and 24hd
I am grouping these because my opinion is the same.
There is no need for all that room...especially when you can zoom in. I'm sorry but it seems excessive. Now mind you i'm 5'3....100lbs....hands with a size 5 ring. I'm small. so maybe i need less room....but it just seems like a waste of money and space.
why pay upwards to 2k when you can pay 1k for the 13 hd AND get portability?
My feels on the companion and companion hybrid:
I HAD the option to get one of these. Here is why I DID NOT.
First of all, watch this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHyIDeHjw_8 <--this was a HUGE game changer for me.
As far as the companion goes.....frankly...I'm NOT OKAY with carrying that around. If it gets stolen you'll probably go on a killing spree. You'll feel like shit.
Also....who does detailed work like that outside of the comfort of your workspace/studio/home. one thousand extra bucks to be able to go...probably just sketch in the park on sai? wtf?
As far as the companion hybrid goes. I was ALMOST convinved till i watched the above video. As a galaxy note owner, buying a hybrid made no sense.
The hybrid has the same O.S. (almost) as the galaxy note.
So on the go....you only get samsung apps to art on. you CANNOT PUT SAI ON THE HYBRID.
So rather than spending 1,500 dollars on the hybrid...which would probably only mostly be put to work at home....
you can get the galaxy note 10 for 330 dollars refurbished. which has a standard stylus MADE BY WACOM
AND a 13hd.
And if you lose a 330 dollar galaxy its better than 'OH FUCK LEFT MY CINTIQ AT STARBUCKS'.
Let's be serious.
So today i'm the very happy owner of an intuos 4, a cintiq 13hd, and a galaxy note tablet.
And I couldn't be happier. <3
Edit+
I do recommend an ergotron for any cintiq. As they are otherwise very non ergonomic. I plan to get one soon myself.